NEW BOOK Kicks up Koran Dust

The sound of MuezzinDestination: Istanbul and the Middle East

Book: The Topkapi Secret (What They Learn About the Koran Could Change the World…or Cost Them Their Lives) by Terry Kelhawk (NEW September, 2010)

Am I in danger reviewing this book?  The flaks for Kelhawk’s book are going out of their way to persuade us that she is in mortal danger–so doesn’t it follow that a reviewer might also be targeted? Are their dangerous secrets in the Koran?

Like the subtitle of The Topkapi Secret says, asking questions about the Koran can get a person in trouble. This book deals with religious warfare–but not the replay of the Crusades with Muslims against Christians. Here we have a group of Muslim scholars who want to perform historical and scientific studies on the Koran endangered by radical Muslims who believe that the Koran is unchanged and unchangeable and should not be analyzed.

The main character, a Palestinian graduate student who studies the Koran with his father in their home in Lebanon, says he is A.D.D. (Adult Deficiency Disorder). I would say that The Topkapi Secret has the same affliction.  Part thriller, part religious history lesson and part travelogue– and oh, yeah, romance– it doesn’t settle down in any one spot very long.

The settings flash by as Mohammad, the grad student, jokester, and womanizer bounces around from Lebanon to Turkey to Holland to Great Britain to Palestine to Syria to Morocco. Following him, we learn all about (and I do mean ALL about) the history of the Koran, the study of ancient documents, factions in the Muslim religion, the layout of the Topkapi Palace and the lives of the sultans and the Harem, present day Palestine and Lebanon, and quite a bit about the Arabic language. Does that sound like a lot of learning?

Whether you want to sign up for this course depends on how much you want to know. Author and professor Terry Kelhawk lists extensive research sources, and claims great experience, although the statement “Award winning writer, speaker and teacher”…doesn’t count as facts.

I read a great description of the secrets of Topkapi and it’s  Sacred Relics Chamber, in Strolling Through Istanbul, not to mention an intriguing 1999 Atlantic article about Koranic study. So I was very curious about the subject. And you know that I’m a sucker for travelogues!

However, The Topkapi Secret only picks up speed and interest when we “cut to the chase.”  Fortunately, there are plenty of exciting chases.  The thriller aspect of the book is better done than the over-lengthy exposition.

I had a problem relating to either of the main characters.  Mohammad performs deeds of daring-do, even murder, and he does serious scholarly work, but his personality seems stuck in 7th grade with silly jokes and “Ha, ha.” Yes, the author actually has him saying, “Ha, ha.” It is hard to take him seriously as the James Bond of Koran scholars.

The female protagonist, a professor of literature and feminism at Berkely, who gets mixed up in all of this through some far-fetched connections, comes across a bit more believable, but some of her actions, like playing dress up and reliving the life in the Topkapi harem, don’t ring true for a supposedly serious scholar.

Bottom line: Great idea for a book but awkwardly crafted by a first-time novelist.

I always enjoy literary visits to mid-Eastern countries and learning more about their cultures, but I cannot unreservedly recommend the book.  You’ll have to decide for yourself. You may like it especially if you read it for the thriller aspect and let the overload of information wash over you. And who knows, maybe we’ll get lucky and a more skillful book on this intriguing subject will show up on the shelves.

Are you aware of the controversy about studying the Koran?  Which of the places that this book goes would you like to travel to? Have you ever visited the Sacred Relics Chamber at Topkapi?  Now THAT’s high on my wish list!

The Topkapi Secret was provided by the publisher for review. And the lovely photo above comes from Flickr, courtesy of a Creative Commons license. Click on the photo for more info and to see more about the photographer, Steven Corso.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

About Vera Marie Badertscher

A freelance writer who loves to travel. When she is not traveling she is reading about travel. When she is not reading or traveling, she is sharing with the readers of A Traveler's Library, or recreating her family's past at Ancestors In Aprons . She has written for Reel Life With Jane, Life is a Trip and other websites. Also co-author of a biography, Quincy Tahoma, The Life and Legacy of a Navajo Artist. Contact Vera Marie by e-mail.

13 thoughts on “NEW BOOK Kicks up Koran Dust

  1. I’ve always wanted to explore the Middle East, but I’ll admit that I’m a little nervous, being an American female. I always worry about making some terrible faux pas that will get me into serious trouble.

  2. The topic sounds fascinating, but based on your review I have to wonder if it would be one of those books that have me constantly trying to remember who’s who.

  3. A few more comments from the peanut gallery… it was mentioned that as a first-time novelist, tackling the deep and often dangerous topic of Quranic historical and scientific validity was a heafty task. Having been a student myself of Quranic history and text I have often said, ‘It’s like trying to drink from a fire hydrant.” In my opinion though, Kelhawk has successfully orchestrated a novel that is deep enough to effectively uncover the history of the Topkapi Codices while keeping the reader interested in the characters and flow of the book. The banter between the characters helped to keep things light and I felt that the multiple locations that Angela and Mohammed found themselves in were a creative way to include the many parts of the Islamic World in the search.
    It is unfortunate to me that only a few sentences can negatively impact an individual’s desire to search a topic that is to this day so little studied, so I will add my few sentences to encourage those who enjoy world travel, well researched study and a good mystery story to pick up a copy of The Topkapi Secret.

    1. I welcome all these opposing points of view on the Topkapi Secret. After all, my opinion is just one person’s opinion. Although if you look at the Amazon page, you’ll see that Publisher’s Weekly agreed with me.
      It provides a service to the readers of A Traveler’s Library to hear arguments on the other side. So thanks, Lindsay, Lily and Barbara.

  4. It’s definitely not a good idea to cast aside reading The Topkapi Secret over a few “Ha-ha’s”! The main character finds himself funny, a point well made by the author. There is no doubt characters such as these exist in Middle Eastern culture. I am surprised you have not encountered any in your travels. I agree with your point “you may have to decide for yourself” since I personally appreciate the carefully researched information offered in this book through a fun adventure. I plan to read some of Terry Kelhawk’s referenced materials as a follow up!!

  5. I have lived and traveled extensively in the Middle East and have many friends, male and female there! The Topkapi Secret revealed much I did not know regarding the history and controversy of the Quran. The Palestinian character was real, in accordance with many I have met/know there. I related to Angela, an educated woman, driven by her convictions. As a world traveler I thoroughly enjoyed the various locals as the story developed. I look forward to further books from this knowledgable first novelistf

  6. Like others, I love the idea behind the book–almost a Dan Brown for the Middle East, but I think at your suggestion I’ll pass. A book you really should pick up, although not technically a travelogue but more of a thrilled with plenty of travel thrown in is Daniel Silva.

  7. Sounds interesting, though the protagonist sounds a bit immature from your description! The subject matter interests me and if I had a copy, I’d read it, but I’ll probably not go out of my way to buy it…

  8. Sounds intriguing. It’s too bad that it is a first-novel. Perhaps someone else will take this idea and craft it in a better-written form. I may still download if for the kindle for the heck of it though. It caught my attention if nothing else.

Comments are closed.