San Miguel Island, Haven or Hell?

San Miguel Island book cover


Destination: San Miguel Island, Channel Islands National Park, California

Book: San Miguel by T. C. Boyle



I have never given much thought to the Channel Islands off Santa Barbara, California, including San Miguel Island.  I was vaguely aware they are there–out in the Pacific just beyond view from shore.  And that they are wildlife preserves, suitable for visiting by sea, or going ashore if you want to hike and explore nature–but only with a permit, I figured.


San Miguel Island


In fact there are five islands, and they comprise the Channel Islands National Park, one of the least-visited of America’s National Parks. Because of their isolation, like the Galapagos, they are chock full of odd and singular species.

But in San Miguel, author T. C. Boyle is interested in the odd and singular species of humans who inhabited San Miguel Island long before it became a National Park.  His fictionalized history follows two families–the Waters family in the late 1800’s and the Lester family in the 1930’s.  Boyle deftly tells the story of these families from the point of view of the women. His novel explores not only human psychology but also sharply defines the enormous changes in attitudes, beliefs, and the effect of technology, communications and war on American life over a period that equals an average life time.

All the island inhabitants are refugees of a sort–from the horrors of war (Civil War and First World War), from illness, from loneliness, or from too much stress.

San Miguel Island seals

The narrator in the first section, Marantha, who is dying of tuberculosis is brought here by her domineering Civil War veteran husband with the promise that the pure air will help her. She loathes the island and finally, furiously demands to be taken off. The husband has invested her money in a sheep ranch on San Miguel Island, and the manual labor and chipped china, noisy seals, and constant filth make life unbearable.

Marantha’s adopted daughter, a bored teenager trapped far from civilization with only a none-too-bright teenage farm worker to entertain her, constantly schemes and tries to get her way by seduction. Edith, the daughter, narrates the second section of the book, and my heart went out to her.  A third woman in the household, who does not get to tell her own story, is the Irish maid/cook, nearly as young as the daughter, but without her big ideas.

The male author’s hat-trick of capturing the voice and personality of these three women and their various stages of disgruntlement is not the end of his genius. Next he turns to the story of Elise Lester, brought to the island after the first family has left so that she and her husband can care for the sheep and try to buy the land from the owner.  Her husband also relishes the peace and quiet to recover from shell shock suffered in World War I. The second family is as chipper and cheerful as the first is sad and resentful.

San Miguel Island

Where Marantha saw only the constant wind and the blowing dust, Elise sees beauty and opportunity. In their twelve years on San Miguel Island, the Lester family adds two little girls to their family, and their life progresses from once-a month supply ships to an airplane dropping in supplies; from loneliness to being overwhelmed with visitors; from isolation and quiet to the constant noise of the radio broadcasting news of War.

While the natural landmarks on the San Miguel Island are the same, minus the sheep, the two houses described so vividly in the novel are long gone. I’ll wager that the novel will leave you wanting to explore San Miguel Island on your own.  The larger question, still rattling around in my mind, is “How would I react to living on an island out of touch with the busy world I know?” and “Would I be an Elise? An Edith? A Marantha?”  “And how much of your happiness depends on the person you are sharing the life with rather than the place? ”

That’s what good novels do–they leave you thinking. And this is a very good novel indeed.

Travel to the San Miguel Island and the Channel Islands

The National Parks web site will fill you in on various methods of transportation to San Miguel Island and the other Channel Islands.

Start in Ventura, California, where the park headquarters is located, and where you will depart for the islands.

Take what you need with you, because there are no stores on the islands.

If you are spending a night or two–you’ll be camping.

The NPS leads hikes and dives.

But if you can’t get to the Channel Islands in person, you can watch videos of live hikes and live dives.  Here’s the archive of past hikes and dives on video, and you can find the times when you can watch a live hike or dive on your computer at the same website.

Here’s a look at what what it would be like to visit San Miguel Island  today. A 7-minute video on You-Tube.

The photos here are in the public domain and acquired from the NPS Channel Islands website. A link to Amazon is an affiliate link, which means that if you purchase something from Amazon through links on this page, you will be supporting A Traveler’s Library (even though it costs you no more to shop that way).  The book was provided to me by the publisher for review, which has no effect on my opinion. I tell you what I think.


Print Friendly, PDF & Email

About Vera Marie Badertscher

A freelance writer who loves to travel. When she is not traveling she is reading about travel. When she is not reading or traveling, she is sharing with the readers of A Traveler's Library, or recreating her family's past at Ancestors In Aprons . She has written for Reel Life With Jane, Life is a Trip and other websites. Also co-author of a biography, Quincy Tahoma, The Life and Legacy of a Navajo Artist. Contact Vera Marie by e-mail.

2 thoughts on “San Miguel Island, Haven or Hell?

  1. Traveling and reading goes hand in hand. I can not imagining traveling without reading. And I met so many people with so different books. I love when I found a good book to read – add this on my list!

Comments are closed.